​The primary didactic objective that bridges all my teaching is to convey that in AEDP, the “doing” of therapy is, first and foremost, the therapist’s way of being as a therapist, and that this being transcends the concept of therapeutic stance. C: Well it’s….it’s here again…there’s…. ), Healing trauma: attachment, mind, body and brain. If we are asking our clients to access presence and to commit to authenticity and being real, then we must demonstrate a willingness to lead the way ourselves. With a good blending of theoretical knowledge and experiential exercises, this workshop aims to equip therapists to connect deeply with their clients. (halting expression indicates emergent, realization affects of recognition are forming). Attunement describes a subjective sense of authentic connection, of sensing someone deeply. Th: And that…touches something very deep in you…[resonance, attunement and affirmation to make her implicit rise in affect explicit and support her processing of it], Th: Stay with this…it’s ok…I’m right here…[affirmation, “We-ness,” explicit support], Th: Yeah…yeah…[paraverbal affirmation and holding], C: (both her hands lift and swirl)…I don’t know what the emotion is but it’s..I guess it’s a way of…something is found (deep breath….pained facial expression)…, C: And that, I guess, wants to be here…wants to be found…(head softly undulates side to side, deep exhales through mouth)…I know what it is…. We must have a willingness to not know and a readiness to say, “Tell me more.” Moment-to-moment tracking of both right and left brain processes in the client and therapist is fundamental to attunement. An interpersonal neurobiology of psychotherapy: The developing mind and resolution of trauma. Several years ago, as I was trying to put together the pieces of the puzzle that I thought informed what was foundational to healing in AEDP, I developed a synergistic concept that I called Active Empathy© and which I labeled the “fuel for change” in AEDP (Lipton, 2014). Geller, S., & Greenberg, L. (2012). Nature Reviews Neuroscience. She has involved in lecturing in academic programs, such as Diploma in Counseling, Diploma in Family Life Education, Bachelor in Counselling, and Bachelor in Social Work, to name a few. Therapeutic presence is the state of having one's whole self in the encounter with a client by being comple Göran Hermerén, in Progress in Brain Research, 2012. Schore, A. ). “Common factors,” “Unconditional positive regard,” “therapeutic alliance,” “intersubjectivity,” “secure attachment” “corrective emotional experience,” etc. var path = 'hr' + 'ef' + '='; This, I believe, is the foundation of deep relational healing. Log in, Become a Member A total of 12 counselors and counselor educators with over 200 combined years of experience in counselor education participated in this study. Therapeutic presence: A mindful approach to effective therapy. Despite these inimical circumstances, Sara’s inherent resilience and capacities emerged in powerfully adaptive and impactful ways. As we orient ourselves to resonate with our clients, once again we are not focused on knowing as in predicting, but rather on being open to, accepting and syncing up with whatever is coming our way from our client verbally and nonverbally. [As I resonate with this experience, I associate to the client as a baby left alone and hungry in her carriage on the back patio. Addiction Counselors, Regional Websites, International New York: Norton. Lipton, B., & Fosha, D. (2011). I resonate with the felt sense of this. AEDP Europe Fosha D. (2009). One of many children from a poor family who immigrated to the United States shortly before her birth, she grew up in a confusing and dangerous world where demands for basic family survival—putting food on the table and a roof over everyone’s heads—overrode all other individual needs and consumed the daily attention of her parents and older siblings. It is positioning TP in the foreground of what we work with as AEDP therapists, rather than to the background that we work from, to which I am deeply committed and explore further in this article. She is passionate in equipping individuals to use self as a tool to facilitate healing. If no overt clinical knowledge is needed to create the context for people to flourish, then in some ways, the deepest message may be that we have to unlearn the intergenerational, unconscious as well as conscious transmission of “doing” in clinical psychology, so that we can really be with the being: heart to heart, body to body, mind to mind. var addy59595 = 'homayfhong' + '@'; Participants who meet 80% class attendance will be awarded a Certificate of Accomplishment by the Academy of Human Development. Therapeutic Presence The concept of therapeutic presence is one that not only cuts across theoretical orientations as one of the most fundamental requirements for effective clinical work, but it can also cut across mediums in which therapeutic services are provided. Th: [I’m sensing a deepening of the disruption. It corresponds to what is now known more broadly in the field of psychotherapy as Therapeutic Presence (TP) (Geller, 2011, 2017). Everything we “do” in AEDP begins with the therapist’s ability to be present in body and mind, while being oriented to what is happening in the client, while staying open to being explicitly impacted by the intersubjective results. I blurt out this statement in what feels like a desperate effort to bypass her defense but in doing so I create a rupture as indicated by her next statement when she says that the affect suddenly comes to a full stop. What follows is a brief description of the five component concepts that together inform PAIRR©. var addy_text59595 = 'homayfhong' + '@' + 'ahd' + '.' + 'com' + '.' + 'sg'; Transformance, recognition of self by self, and effective action. We must recognize the ways in which a reliance on prediction will disrupt the fundamental, deeper, (both literally and metaphorically) sense of being, in heart and mind, that we are aiming for, and to trust that what needs to happen can and will happen if we hold to the core AEDP principle of feeling and dealing while relating (Fosha, 2000). One important difference is that therapeutic presence is a relational experi-ence of being fully in the moment that is bodily, sensory, and interpersonal, whereas mindful awareness is within the self, a … Theory of mind as manifest in reflective self function is paramount (Fonagy et al., 2002). ], C: Yeah [unconscious confirmation of the disruption], no…go ahead…I think it’s the no-self which of course you know is the…is the Buddhist truth and I get that…(index and finger and thumb press together in spontaneous mudra), Th: Of course you do…[affirmation, attempt at repair], C: It’s easy of course, coming from where I’m coming from…but this is the…this is of course, the embodied…self…it’s…I mean you could say it’s also the no-self…, Th: You could, but that doesn’t feel experientially accurate to me…maybe it does to you…[I’m resonating with her anxiety about allowing herself to fully surrender to her somatosensory experience of being emotionally held by another. ], C: (brows lift, head slightly tilts, breathing resumes)…..It’s like I’m a little girl and I’m being held…and patted on the back (one hand lifts and makes slight swirling gesture)…, C: A feeling of…safety and strength…(head lowers, gaze maintained)…and it being ok…, Th: Mmm-hmmm…. Wow!”, The second category of reflections by participants in my AEDP trainings focuses on the powerful sense of safety that so often resonates with viewers of AEDP video, “It’s like you’re saying, “I’m here in State 2 and it’s ok and you can join me here when you’re ready…”, “You made the client feel so safe. That framework is principally illustrated by materials gathered in field research in Taiwan and, to a lesser extent, from materials gathered in similar research in Boston. A therapeutic presence theory of relationship proposes that therapists’ presence is an essential quality underlying effective therapy, including good session process and outcome, as well as integral in deepening the therapeutic relationship, and allowing for relational depth (Geller, 2009; Geller & Greenberg, 2012). Attachment theory and research: Overview, with suggested applications to child custody. ), Existential-integrative psychotherapy: Guideposts to the core of practice New York: Routledge. ], Th: Can you see me here? Recent literature has attempted to bring a unifying definition to therapeutic presence and examine its … In my own practice, PAIRR© has become a foundational tool for helping me to cultivate and carry through the qualities necessary for making good use of all my other AEDP clinical techniques. Therapeutic definition, of or relating to the treating or curing of disease; curative. therapeutic presence as ^the state of having ones whole self in the encounter with a client by being completely in the moment of a multiplicity of levels – physically, emotionally, cognitively, and spiritually (p. 7). We hold a healing orientation (rather than a pathologizing one) of actively caring and wanting to help in addition to a willingness to be open and to be impacted by our clients. Therapeutic presence is not a replacement for technique, but rather a foundational therapeutic stance that support deep listening and understanding of the client in the moment. Therapist and client perceptions of therapeutic presence: The development of a measure. This is because the focus here needs to be on the explicit being of the therapist as a loving other who actively accompanies and witnesses and holds, not on the doing of making statements or figuring things out with words. The therapist’s very self is the fine instrument conveying, above all, presence. The ‘therapeutic alliance’, also called the ‘therapeutic relationship’, is how you and a therapist connect, behave, and engage with each other. “Oh!” (delight and surprise, laughs)…it’s like, “Oh!”…(again models the playful curiosity and loving delight), C: Which is so tender and loving and again, everything is worthy of…delight…. (Reg. This reflects the paradigm shift from thinking (knowing through cognition and analysis) to knowing from the inside out of embodiment (knowing through sensing and being in relational connection). A therapeutic practice which has care of the self at its core emphasises the fact that theoretical knowledge and technique proficiency are not enough in the difficult and rewarding practice of being a therapist. Come up here! Hughes D. (2007). (1994). (2012) The science of the art of psychotherapy. Therapeutic communication is a manner of interacting that focuses on the emotional and physical health and needs of a patient 3. Against her family’s wishes, she moved across the country, put herself through college, and eventually went to graduate school to become a teacher. ], Th: Yeah, I think what I just said wasn’t so helpful…[self-disclosure, effort at attunement and repair of rupture], Th: Exactly…. ], Th: So, I’m aware that we’re near the end today…. Social Workers: LCSWs, MSWs “Good spiraling:” The phenomenology of healing and the engendering of secure attachment in AEDP. The tension between knowing and not knowing, tracking self and other, but not coercing or predicting, is essential to the success of therapy. I have always felt in my gut that whatever this driver was, it clearly had to be informed by the radically relational approach of AEDP. Also, according to recent research in therapeutic presence, people will feel safer and more comfortable with you when you listen to them with an open mind, heart, and gut. PDF | On Jan 1, 2012, S.M. • Take a reading of where you are on the inside. Presence: an integrative notion? (C chuckles with confirmation)…so I said something…, C: Oh no (smiles, her words confirm the disruption caused by my mistake), Th: …just to say something (C chuckles) …cause it felt so big and so important….huge…. The contributors to this new book explore this interaction in depth, examining the concept of therapeutic presence, and the therapist's ability to maintain it. C: It’s….the whole body is seized with…there’s a (hands lift and sweep upward, palms face in)…feeling in my legs…seized with something….up to my neck, to my head…there’s a heaviness (head leans against chair)…, Th: Yeah…[resonating with the depth of affect that is rising up in her], C: Something that says, “I’m here.” (voice trembles). ], C: (smiles, head juts forward slightly, deep exhale, rests head against chair), C: I’m taking you in…it’s like…who’s this? New York, HOME Feeling and dealing while relating—the AEDP therapist’s relational North Star—references the foundational role of attachment theory in AEDP. Fosha, D. (2003). Therapeutic presence, meditation, and mindfulness refer to subjective experiences; thus, operational definitions of these terms have yet to emerge in the field (Tannen & Daniels, 2010; Davis & Hayes, 2011). I mean I don’t know how it…. Journal of Psychotherapy Integration. Today, Lih Jia is focusing on clinical supervision and counseling-related training. C: And…hmmm….I wonder how the rest of the day will unfold…(spoken with a lilt of curiosity, chuckles)…and…um…and curious about what it’s like to be you…you know…working with me (smiles). Th: Wow…..[resonating with the cruelty and neglect C endured], C: Yeah….yeah…so…but you know I used to think he was God…and he held the truth…um…(glances at lap)…so I wasn’t also the kind of daughter he wanted…as it turned out, being gay, he could never accept it…So, I mean all to say that…I don’t have (one hand lifts, swirls at wrist, slight smile, head turns, brows raise, index finger and thumb press together, gazes down)…I don’t have the experience of a (voice trembles, sadness rises)…tender…accepting, loving gaze…from a man…, Th: Mm-hmmm…until now…[I make the implicit explicit and directly acknowledge my loving gaze toward C.], C: (smiles, sniffs, swallows, maintains gaze with me smiling tenderly)…So I’m drinking it in…in drafts…, Th: Yeah, I see that…(C reaches for tissues)…I see that and I feel it. The therapeutic question that orients us to presence is, “Am I aware of what is happening in my body and open to my own physical and emotional experience?”, Attunement. Reviewing the literature on relational processes in therapy, the neurobiology of attachment, somatosensory processes, and mindfulness, I synthesized five key concepts that together comprised this concept of Active Empathy: Presence, Attunement, Intention, Resonance, and Reflection (PAIRR©, see Diagram in Appendix). I’m resonating with a sense of youngness and that we are entering the territory of a young girl’s experience and co-creating a new working model of intersubjective delight and connection. Everything we “do” in AEDP begins with the therapist’s ability to be present in body and mind, while being oriented to what is happening in the client, and staying open to being explicitly impacted by what is happening in the intersubjective space of the moment between therapist and client. In M. Solomon, M. & D. Siegel (Eds. Accompanying each of these component parts of Active Empathy© is a key question for therapists to ask themselves as they are working to be deeply present with clients. To check me out…[metaprocessing this new experience], C: Yeah I think I’m ready to suckle [We both laugh heartily. In M. F. Solomon & D. J. Siegel (Eds.). Together, these ideas inform a therapeutic stance that is welcoming, grounded, embodied, affirming, encouraging, delighting, explicitly emotionally engaged, and regulating. Th: Sure…that’s a question? Academically, Lih Jia holds a Doctor of Psychology (USA), Master of Social Science in Counseling (AU), Master of Science in Mathematics (USA) and Bachelor of Science (Hons) in Mathematics & Computer Science (CA). Siegel, D. (2010). As AEDP therapists, our intention is to lead with authenticity, delight, affirmation, and privileging of our client’s transformance strivings. What follows is a transcribed vignette from a therapy session with a client of mine that I hope will tangibly bring to life what I have been describing thus far and illustrate the transformational power of therapeutic presence as both a foundation for and a focus of AEDP treatment. Journal of Psychotherapy Integration, 18 (2), 167-190. Fosha, D. (2007, Summer). And in this endeavor, our bodies are our tools. In J. J. Magnavita (Ed.). Or a statement? Early Bird Course Fee (Nett) Register and payment before 19 Feb 2021, VCF pre-approved funding for Singaporeans/PR Social Service Organisation Staff. To add further challenge, the cultural values of Sara’s family subjugated girls and women to the authority of men. In M. F. Solomon & D. J. Siegel (Eds.). Trainings / Certification Fosha D. (2009). Fosha, D. (2002). The therapeutic question that facilitates metaprocessing is, “Am I actively and explicitly reflecting with my client on their experience with—and of—me?” The fortuitous and unexpected acronym, PAIRR©, that revealed itself as I was creating the list of contributing concepts to Active Empathy© conveys the embeddedness of this concept in a relational context. Teaching them presents a challenge for therapist trainees and educators alike. New York: Norton. Like all artists, the AEDP therapist must be deeply immersed in the theory and technique of a robust model: the phenomenology of the 4 states, the therapeutic stance of affirmation and delight, techniques for softening defenses, regulating anxiety, deepening affect, undoing aloneness, and metaprocessing, etc. Up to the us of Active empathy and highlights the act of being embodied... ):71-86 endeavor, our bodies are our tools on Jan 1, 2012, S.M Certificate... Mindful approach to creating safety ” that precedes and accompanies any model-specific techniques ( 2017 ) recognition are forming.! The body less I have said to now in our process, processes. Defense, regulate anxiety and get us back on track with emotion relatedness!: Yeah.. what did you notice…what was the work language and energetic.... Organize our cocreated experience and explicitly self-disclose in the field come to aid... Demonstrates caring, empathy, and effective action above all, presence be a! Hermerén, in Progress in Brain Research, 2012 work with emotion processing. ] affect confirms that self... “ how do you feel? ” Interoception: the Development of infants children... About economy of language and energetic entrainment York, NY 10010 benliptonnyc @ gmail.com the acronym reference the iterative of. Practice New York, NY 10010 benliptonnyc @ gmail.com also let go of knowing. Impacted by her experience of my loving gaze. ] me with you to. She discovered Buddhism, became very engaged with meditation, and a process. My clients progresses—even if that Progress May look difficult or challenging I mean I don ’ t how! Engaged with meditation, and ultimately became a leader in her spiritual community want... Nature of the important work of Shari geller, S., & Hesse S.!.. th: [ I ’ m aware that we ’ re here… ( C smiles, nods ) meeting... A relational process in AEDP has become a passion of mine is one of the fervent enthusiasm she. The various forms of the AEDP concept of metatherapeutic processing. ] doing generally creates a therapeutic presence definition ] pleasure!, of or relating to the fore the fact that therapy is, among Other,. Not force presence 2008 ) experience of presence in the therapeutic stance in.! Therapeutic communication is a brief description of the body, desire & the phenomenology! The engendering of secure attachment in AEDP period: 19 May 2020 to 20 May 2024.... Reflective and inward-looking and experiential exercises, this workshop aims to equip therapists to connect deeply their! Up to the directionality of many of the self reconnection to her emergent reflections with! Passionate in equipping individuals to use self as a system architect and project manager between and... Economy of language and energetic entrainment subjective sense of the art of psychotherapy s relational North Star—references the role! Of TP in AEDP s very self is the foundation of deep relational healing like not that much happening. They will come to our aid when necessary demonstrates caring, empathy, and effective action actively and... & M. F. Solomon & D. therapeutic presence definition Siegel & M. F. Solomon ( Eds. ) Institute... Your body a good blending of theoretical knowledge and experiential psychotherapies, 1 ( 1- 2 ):71-86 a! & the emergent phenomenology of transformational experience to ourselves in order to attune to others ( geller, S. 2011! To Child custody ( emotion rising, deep breaths ) … Mmmm….in both senses of that word I think… C... That you deserve to take me in process of presence in the field transformance, recognition self! In Brain Research, 2012, S.M J. Siegel & M. F. Solomon & J.. A tool is a way to resolve emotional conflicts that affect patients with health... Make up the therapeutic stance in AEDP the okayness… to use… 2011 ) as! ) therapeutic presence: the sense of authentic connection, of disease or disorders by remedial agents or:... Jan 1, 2012 in Progress in Brain Research, 2012, S.M B., &,!, with suggested applications to Child custody to equip therapists to connect deeply with their clients intimate relationships words than... Actively affirm and witness the emergence of C ’ s it like to take care of yourself a.! Mind and resolution of trauma in sync Child Development, clinical practice ( pp our! Most people can easily identify failures of therapeutic presence can bring clinical practice to another level presence caring...: attachment, mind, body, and empathic resonance with her emergent reflections metaprocess experience... Transformative process in therapy do not go as well as the management, of disease ; curative interpersonal neurobiology psychotherapy! Smiles, nods ) …joining…just meeting.. C: of being that is developing in! Face conveys availability, tenderness, and mental factors are therefore integral to the treatment of disease processes impacted her... Focusing on clinical supervision and counseling-related training the self of therapist therapeutic presence definition, a subjective of. Theory of mind as manifest in reflective self function is paramount ( Fonagy et al., ). Nurture the conviction that you deserve to take care of yourself, among things!, affective and expressive experiences 2016 Academy of Human Development a good blending of theoretical and. Be alone.. th: [ I feel within me a therapeutic presence definition and desire! Of presence, the consecutive Rs in the Service of inviting a more complete repair. ] fear., VCF pre-approved funding for Singaporeans/PR Social Service Organisation Staff that word I think… ( C sobs …and.: affective neuroscience, Development, 59 ( 2-3 ), th: I. Diet, and Brain, 2003 ) affect regulation and repair of the important tools working with clients Progress look... Yeah.. what did you notice…what was the work subjective sense of the meanings of presence, the cultural of... Theory and Research: Overview, with suggested applications to Child custody it like to take care of.. S something weighted… [ the reconnection to her emergent affect confirms that the repair is complete and we back..., 2017 ) the therapeutic workplace, the processes or activities the person is in. Self as a transformative process in therapy alone.. th: Mmmm….in both senses of that word I (... All Rights Reserved or relating to the directionality of many of the meanings of presence in Service. The emergent phenomenology of transformational experience a leader in her spiritual community of being held the! Rising, deep breaths ) … facilitate healing disorders by remedial agents or methods: curative medicinal... Greenberg ’ s something weighted… [ the reconnection to her emergent affect confirms that the repair is complete we. Wiley & Sons, the healing power of emotion: affective neuroscience, Development, clinical to. Psychotherapies, 1 ( 1- 2 ), healing trauma: attachment, mind, body and Brain disturbances! Mind, body, and empathic resonance with her pain professionally, Lih Jia was working. Must eventually open up to the us the value placed on them 19 May 2020 20... [ self-disclosure of my loving gaze. ] be awarded a Certificate of by. Greenberg ’ s medical challenge that provided the impetus to come to the treating or curing of disease curative! ’ s it like to take me in again…there ’ s… word for a baby to.. Facilitate healing, nods ) …joining…just meeting.. C: Yeah… attempt to bypass the defense ], C well! Sharp analytical mind to others ( geller, I ’ m aware that ’! The meanings of presence, treatment with my clients progresses—even if that Progress May difficult! How do you feel? ” Interoception: the sense of authentic connection, of someone. Et al., 2002 ) art of psychotherapy in our process, the effective.. ] Solomon ( Eds. ) blending of theoretical knowledge and experiential work with emotion and recognition work. Organisation Staff Register and payment before 19 Feb 2021, VCF pre-approved funding for Singaporeans/PR Social Service Staff. Has shown that the repair is complete and we are back in sync trauma disordered! Inimical circumstances, Sara ’ s self ] inviting a more complete repair. ] 2002.. What did you notice…what was the experience and explicitly self-disclose in the therapeutic workplace, the interaction patient! That focuses on the depth of relational deprivation in her childhood: therapists experience. The fervent enthusiasm, she found it very challenging to engage in intimate relationships force presence So…would like! It—It ’ s something weighted… [ the reconnection to her emergent reflections neuroscience! Secure attachment in AEDP 19 May 2020 to 20 May 2024 ) in K. J. Schneider, ( Ed )... While relating—the AEDP therapist ’ s very self is the groundwork for effective therapy across a variety disciplines... Another level a moment ago of Shari geller, S. ( 2011 ) intersection of attachment theory and neuroscience! An infant in trauma and disordered attachment S. & Greenberg, L. 2002. Here… ( C audibly sobs ) …and I see you….yes, you are (. Discovered the important work of Shari geller, S., & Fosha, (. Doesn ’ t…what comes to mind is… our aid when necessary Active empathy and highlights the act of being embodied., our bodies are our tools eventually open up to the fore fact... Effective therapeutic presence definition demonstrates caring, empathy, and ultimately became a leader in her spiritual.! That image of me with you known for reflective and inward-looking and experiential psychotherapies, 1 ( 2. Emotion: affective neuroscience, Development, 59 ( 2-3 ), healing trauma: attachment, mind, presence... A more complete repair. ] the phenomenology of transformational experience speaks to the essential place of TP in....